Dexter

[Corrin]

Only one more day till the end begins. I truly feel that Spoiler:

show spoiler

Trinity is going to come out alive this season and Dexter will end up in big, big trouble

.

[Zombie Fred]

Great episode tonight, the last five minutes were intense as hell with Arthur and Dexter. Finale can't come soon enough.

[MeganGrass]

Oh. My. God.

Dexter is getting too sloppy!

Spoiler:

show spoiler

He should have killed Trinity when he "had the fucking chance".

Instead, he's left fingerprints on a cup in a bomb-shelter (playing with cement in the floor, with the aide of water from a cup he handled without gloves...WTF?), he's killing innocent people (The hollywood scumbag was an accident, but the truckdriver was shere stupidity, even if it was to frame someone else for Trinity's crimes), sloppily planting evidence in broad daylight (in a truck+elsewhere), depriving himself of sleep (never a good thing, for anyone), inadvertantly showing Rita his "bad side" by punching out the neighbor (funny though, she still falls for his emulated "protect family" 'emotions') - The list goes on and on. He's just begging to get caught.

The code is fucking broken and shattered. His priorities changed too much when he tried to find a mentor in Trinity, and ignoring the advice of his dark passenger, and I do believe it may just lead to his downfall. Though I could be wrong - wouldn't be the first time.

On a related note, I participated in the live chat, after the show. <- What a waste of time. The most irrelevent questions from fans got asked and answered - the same typical BS that any real Dexter fan should know, they still opted to answer these stupid questions. There were a few good ones, however - none noteworthy, however (IMO).

[Corrin]

Dexter is gonna have to miracle his ass out of trouble to not end up caught and in prison at the end of the season finale.

[Corrin]

Last night's episode was just about the bitchenest thing that I ever did see!

Spoiler:

show spoiler

I hope Dexter catches that slut Rita cheating on him, so he'll have something on her if she ever catches on to him. Saw Christine beeing the killer last ep...obvious...didn't see her being Trinity's daughter. I yelled "WHAT?" at mah TV

[Humor Tumor]

I've watched season 1 so far and I love it. It's probably among my top 4 shows next to Battlestar Galactica, Bones and Firefly

[YamiYumes]

With that said, exactly how would someone confront a loved one (whether they can solely identify the emotion of love within themself, or not), sit them down and tell them, "I kill people".

Well, he never really tells Rita in the book series. He realized Cody acting a lot like he did when he was a child, and instead begins to teach him Harry's Code. Everyone else, for the most part, remained blissfully unaware, just as he meant them to.

No matter how hard he could try to explain his misplaced sense of justice, in our world, they would lock this guy up and throw away the key, or even worse, the death penalty - something that noone Dexter knows nor any amount of money could save him from.

Well, you seem to forget that some people believe in eye for an eye, which is essentially what Dexter is doing. So if he waits and observes what kind of a person they are, he could very well tell someone and (depending) they not freak out. He wouldn't tell someone like Doakes, naturally, since people like him are very black and white about murder, but other people may sympathize. Especially if they witness the unjustice of the justice system on a daily basis and grow frustrated with their inability to truly bring an offender to justice.

I think that's part of the, dare I say "beauty", of the Dexter TV series - his character has developed, aided by the self-discovery that he too has normal thoughts/emotions/feelings+issues (love for his family, for recent example) while being completely aware of, burdened and hiding what he really is - all of this while trying to lead a "normal" life as a father, husband, and to have success in his work enviroment.

I can think of some good points how Dexter was played-out better as an emotionless human being... but the bottom line, as Yami said, plain socio/psychopaths are unredeemable. They offer nothing. They are nothing. No emotion, no hope for the person's character to develop in any other aspect of life, and even worse, no true answers as to why they are fucked up and how they got to be in that state of mind (then again, I guess that's the "beauty" of the original mystique of Dexter).

Well, they give us reason. When Dexter witnessed that horrific incident when he was a child, that was pretty much the catalyst. And I don't entirely agree upon them being unable to develop as a character. While sociopaths don't feel emotion, they can still continue to grow and learn. I think it would have been interesting to see Dexter deteriorate slowly from strictly following Harry's Code to starting to justify smaller offenses, and beginning to kill more and more.

Something like that enables his character to grow, albeit in a negative way, and still not need emotion or a family to move forward, although the family would be a challenge to this new growth. Especially Cody lol

Personally, I like to know/somewhat understand atleast a slight bit of reason, too, and the television series still delivers that for me - not redemption (I really don't think that's what the producers are aiming for), but rather an insight into the [especially rare] humanistic side of a sociopathic, viglante serial killer.

You had me until the mention of humanistic. There is no humanistic side to a sociopath, really. They are what they are: Emotionless shells of a human being that can, at times, mimic the emotions and personality of one of us, but ultimately feels nothing for anyone other than himself.

And they also gave a reason for Dexter being the way he was, since he witnessed Spoiler:

show spoiler

his parents being brutally murdered in front of him, and he had to sit in that warehouse in their blood for hours.

[MeganGrass]

I had hoped season two or three would swing back a little closer to the books and have Dexter reveal his secret to either the children or at least his sister.

He knew Rita was essential for him to continue doing what he was doing, yet he would never go so far as to say he loved her because he knew he was incapable of it.
...
redeeming a sociopath is impossible, yet they write it as such while trying to keep the rest of the universe as realistic as possible.

With that said, exactly how would someone confront a loved one (whether they can solely identify the emotion of love within themself, or not), sit them down and tell them, "I kill people". No matter how hard he could try to explain his misplaced sense of justice, in our world, they would lock this guy up and throw away the key, or even worse, the death penalty - something that noone Dexter knows nor any amount of money could save him from. I think that's part of the, dare I say "beauty", of the Dexter TV series - his character has developed, aided by the self-discovery that he too has normal thoughts/emotions/feelings+issues (love for his family, for recent example) while being completely aware of, burdened and hiding what he really is - all of this while trying to lead a "normal" life as a father, husband, and to have success in his work enviroment.

I can think of some good points how Dexter was played-out better as an emotionless human being... but the bottom line, as Yami said, plain socio/psychopaths are unredeemable. They offer nothing. They are nothing. No emotion, no hope for the person's character to develop in any other aspect of life, and even worse, no true answers as to why they are fucked up and how they got to be in that state of mind (then again, I guess that's the "beauty" of the original mystique of Dexter). Personally, I like to know/somewhat understand atleast a slight bit of reason, too, and the television series still delivers that for me - not redemption (I really don't think that's what the producers are aiming for), but rather an insight into the [especially rare] humanistic side of a sociopathic, viglante serial killer.

[Corrin]

Masuka should have his own TV show. Like, what he does outside of work. It'd be a comedy...or a horror. Or both.

[Bertha]

Actually Spoiler:

show spoiler

he did this in the first episode of season 3...the set up for that boring-ass season

Well... Spoiler:

show spoiler

Dexter eventually found reason to rationalize why killing him wasn't so bad after all. The "code" was broken, but Dexter began to grow and form his own code.

I loved the books and the first, third, and so far the fourth seasons...season two though...not so much. I thought it was terrible. Rita was turned into a character I found to be completely annoying, Lila was just...ugh. Terrible foreshadowing made her fate so obvious. Doakes...I liked where things were going but sadly most of the tension between Doakes and Dexter took a back seat with the whole Lila situation. I had hoped season two or three would swing back a little closer to the books and have Dexter reveal his secret to either the children or at least his sister.

And I agree with Yami....I like book Dexter better than his series portrayal. However, I think some of the background characters in the show are much better than their book counterparts, so it slightly evens out. Everyone should have a friend like Masuka.

[YamiYumes]

They've stated before the series is meant to be a wholly different thing than the books. The series is more about Dexter discovering his humanity he didn't know existed.

It's too bad you gave up on the show because season 4 is really great. I'd put it on the same level as season 2...and they've finally made that cookie-cutter, bland-ass Quinn an interesting character.

Well, the thing that made the book series so interesting to me was the fact that Dexter was wholly comfortable with what he was: a monster. The moment they tried to rewrite him as a redeemable character, it lost a lot of the original pull for me.

It was fascinating for me to read about how he could so easily manipulate those around him, and yet never wholly dissolve into a 'true' monster. He still had codes, still had ethics...yet he felt no emotion. He saw people as things to be used or things to be discarded. He knew Rita was essential for him to continue doing what he was doing, yet he would never go so far as to say he loved her because he knew he was incapable of it.

The closest he gets is with Cody when he realizes that Cody is almost the same as him. Yet, still. It's not love.

That's the reason I was rather hesitant towards the television series to begin with...redeeming a sociopath is impossible, yet they write it as such while trying to keep the rest of the universe as realistic as possible.

[Corrin]

I adore the books the series is based off of, but it seemed to me like they were trying to make Dexter more...human, instead of keeping with the fact that he's a completely emotionless sociopath who manages to hide it well.

The first few seasons were alright, but the moment Rita had a baby, I was out. lol

They've stated before the series is meant to be a wholly different thing than the books. The series is more about Dexter discovering his humanity he didn't know existed.

It's too bad you gave up on the show because season 4 is really great. I'd put it on the same level as season 2...and they've finally made that cookie-cutter, bland-ass Quinn an interesting character.

[YamiYumes]

I adore the books the series is based off of, but it seemed to me like they were trying to make Dexter more...human, instead of keeping with the fact that he's a completely emotionless sociopath who manages to hide it well.

The first few seasons were alright, but the moment Rita had a baby, I was out. lol

[Vector]

I don't know what is wrong with the people you talked to, but me and all my friends agree that season 2 was the best so far. If you liked the Dexter/Doakes cat & mouse at all...you are in for quite an awesome treat in season 2.

It was Season 3 then. I guess I got them mixed up, I just remember hearing from friends that one season was not good.

[Corrin]

Oh then your in for a treat. Spoiler:

show spoiler

Dexter finally kills an innocent man

Actually Spoiler:

show spoiler

he did this in the first episode of season 3...the set up for that boring-ass season

Watched the entire first season on DVD at my friend's house and enjoyed the hell out of it, but I heard from many people that Season 2 was lame...haven't really watched any of the show since then.

I don't know what is wrong with the people you talked to, but me and all my friends agree that season 2 was the best so far. If you liked the Dexter/Doakes cat & mouse at all...you are in for quite an awesome treat in season 2.