Who's worse: Boll or Anderson?

[Darkmoon]

It's a decent sci-fi horror. I'd definitely say it's not action. It's not the greatest horror ever, true, but compare it to anything Uwe Boll has done, ever.

[P Anderson DIE]

Dont see what the fuss is with Event Horizon heared it was scary? More like an action film and not a very good one at that, Sam Neil is a good actor prob the best thing about the film.

[Darkmoon]

I think that's the important thing...while Anderson's Resident Evil movies are essentially fanfiction based around his wife being forced into the plot and forcing out all other characters, plot elements not related to her and common sense he can, when not filming the mother of his child, make a decent film.

Boll, on the other hand...I've seen BloodRayne and Alone in the Dark and a couple of others. They were all crap, without exception or remorse. The only way the man gets funding is because of German tax cuts for movie investors. Basically they get half the cash back from the goverment before they even start filming, as far as I can tell. And that's the only reason he keeps filiming, because otherwise his films wouldn't make nearly as big a profit, if they made one at all.

Plus, Boll and his boxing crap just makes him look like a complete cock.

[aris13]

Anderson is better. Event horizon is his best work and I really enjoyed Mortal Kombat, the second one was a total disgrace thank god Anderson had nothing to do with it even Johnny Cage was killed off. And his last movie Death race was quite fun.

[missvalentine]

i think Boll is way worse than Anderson ever will be, im not sure if ive ever seen one of bolls films, but i don't ever want to.

i actually don't think Anderson is to bad, ive enjoyed all his films in stupid action movie kind of way, maybe cause i don't really care about film to much, i like games way more.

i thought he did a great job on Event Horizon, and i liked AVP a lot to, and yes i even enjoyed the RE movies, all three of them, there non canon so they don't bother me one bit, except that NEMESIS VS Alice fight that's just stupid.

i actualy enjoyed the movies more than RE4 for some reason, maybe cause RE4 is cannon which pisses me off, but id still rather the first RE movie to be cannon instead of RE4, but that's just me.

[sogar]

Anderson can actually direct though.

[GuardhouseMusic]

I do enjoy MK for its protruding flaws, and that's about it for Anderson. Resident Evil is mediocre to average and the next two films are garbage. I guess I should see Event Horizon at some point.

I haven't seen a single Boll film, but he just disgusts me on so many levels. Though I remember seeing the TV spots for House of the Dead and laughing my ass off. I guess Boll wins, which is kinda sad.

[P Anderson DIE]

They both deserve to be castrated and locked away from the world. How these guys got the opportunity to make movies is beyond me but Anderson has ruinined two of my favorite franchises so he is definatey worse.

[Mr. Spencer]

That was before the BH movies. So he's yet to redeem himself, IMO.

Sam Neill's excellence is long lasting, it will keep Anderson warm and alive during the hibernation months.

[Twist]

Anderson gave us Event Horizon, so he's redeemed himself.

That was before the BH movies. So he's yet to redeem himself, IMO.

[Helegad]

I never thought Anderson was a bad movie-maker anyway.

[Mr. Spencer]

Anderson gave us Event Horizon, so he's redeemed himself.

[Helegad]

I was also wondering if anybody else thought that when I saw the movie in the cinema (I actually sneaked in there; I was 14, and the movie was restricted to 15 and over, so I bought a ticket to Rush Hour 3 and just causally walked into the Extinction cinema )

[Bertha]

How all those zombies fit in that one container I'll never know.

There must have been more than 50.

I'm so glad I wasn't the only one that had a huge wtf moment because of that.

[Corrin]

It's like comparing having to eat shit or maggots for dinner; a really dumb thing to even ask anyone.

So I'll just say that I prefer David Lynch.